I’ve been a religious buyer and player of both EA Sports football games for the past 3 years. And I’ve loved both of them almost equally. Until this year, that is.
The pre-release hype for NCAA was phenomenal, and what was described sounded great — the home-field advantage, toughest stadiums to play in, the expansion of the dynasty mode, all that stuff. I was all geeked up.
Madden didn’t seem to get nearly the same amount of pre-release hype, or maybe I was just looking in the wrong places. Everything I saw was about Ray Lewis and the jinx, or about the collector’s edition they put out. Very little was said about the game play, the Owner mode changes, and things like that.
In past years, I’ve bought NCAA and played it to death for a month until Madden came out. Then they’d always compete for my attention. This year, I played about 8 games of NCAA and lost interest. I don’t like it. At first I thought maybe it was just because my favorite team sucks this season so I was losing lots of games and looking bad in the process … 41-0, 33-3, etc. But I played as a much better team … and still didn’t like it. It’s too slow. Runners and receivers are too slow. Zip passes from strong-armed QBs don’t have much zip. Nothing feels “right”. I don’t know how to describe it — they really overhauled the gameplay AI, and made it worse, I think.
Madden, on the other hand, is even more amazing than I expected. The gameplay is terrific — my RBs and receivers are making cutbacks I’ve never seen before. The defensive control is stunning — individual hot routes and all that. The variety of types of tackles is incredible. It’s fast … well, faster than NCAA at least. And the Owner/Franchise mode stuff … EA Sports Radio, Gameplans, newspapers and email, all of it is fantastic.
Madden is only out two weeks now, compared to 6 weeks for NCAA … but I’ll be wearing out Madden a lot sooner than NCAA this year. Next summer, NCAA will probably be a rent-before-you-buy item.
Am I alone in thinking / feeling like this?
Oh — and running the Seahawks, I’m 5-2 so far in my first year of Franchise mode. Darrell Jackson is having a huge year. And Alex Bannister is actually very effective as the 4th WR. Who knew?
|